Saving History With Sandbags: Climate Change Threatens the Smithsonian
WASHINGTON President Warren Hardings blue silk pajamas. Muhammad Alis boxing gloves. The Star Spangled Banner. Scripts from the television show M*A*S*H. Nearly two million irreplaceable artifacts that tell the American story are housed in the National Museum of American History, part of the Smithsonian Institution, the biggest museum complex in the world. Now, because of climate change, the Smithsonian stands out for another reason: Its cherished buildings are extremely vulnerable to flooding, and some could eventually be underwater. Eleven palatial Smithsonian museums and galleries form a ring around the National Mall, the grand two-mile park lined with elms that stretches from the Lincoln Memorial to the U.S. Capitol. But that land was once marsh. And as the planet warms, the buildings face two threats. Rising seas will eventually push in water from the tidal Potomac River and submerge parts of the Mall, scientists say. More immediately, increasingly heavy rainstorms threaten the museums and their priceless holdings, particularly since many are stored in basements. At the American History Museum, water is already intruding. It gurgles up through the floor in the basement. It finds the gaps between ground-level windows, puddling around exhibits. It sneaks into the ductwork, then meanders the building and drips onto display cases. It creeps through the ceiling in locked collection rooms, thief-like, and pools on the floor. Staff have been experimenting with defenses: Candy-red flood barriers lined up outside windows. Sensors that resemble electronic mouse traps, deployed throughout the building, that trigger alarms when wet. Plastic bins on wheels, filled with a version of cat litter, to be rushed back and forth to soak up the water. So far, the museums holdings have escaped damage. But Were kind of in trial and error, said Ryan Doyle, a facilities manager at the Smithsonian. Its about managing water. An of the Smithsonians vulnerabilities, released last month, reveals the scale of the challenge: Not only are artifacts stored in basements in danger, but floods could knock out electrical and ventilation systems in the basements that keep the humidity at the right level to protect priceless art, textiles, documents and specimens on display. Of all its facilities, the Smithsonian ranks American History as the most vulnerable, followed by its next door neighbor, the National Museum of Natural History. Scientists at the nonprofit group Climate Central expect some land around the two museums will be if average global temperatures rise by 1.5 degrees Celsius, compared with preindustrial levels. The planet has already warmed by 1.1 degrees Celsius and is on track to rise . The American History museum, the Natural History museum and the American Indian museum are all exposed to a so-called 100-year flood one with a 1 percent chance of happening in any given year. Museums at minimal risk of flooding Museums at risk of flooding Areas at risk of flooding .2 MILES Washington Pennsylvania Ave. Constitution Ave. Madison Dr. African American History museum American History museum Natural History museum 3rd St. 4th St. U.S Capitol building National Mall Air and Space museum Washington Monument Hirshhorn museum American Indian museum Museums at minimal risk of flooding Museums at risk of flooding Areas at risk of flooding Washington Pennsylvania Ave. African American History museum Natural History museum Constitution Ave. 3rd St. American History museum National Mall Air and Space museum Washington Monument Hirshhorn museum American Indian museum .2 MILES Museums at minimal risk of flooding Museums at risk of flooding Areas at risk of flooding .2 MILES Washington Pennsylvania Ave. Museums at minimal risk of flooding Museums at risk of flooding Areas at risk of flooding Constitution Ave. Madison Dr. American History museum Natural History museum African American History museum 3rd St. 4th St. U.S Capitol building National Mall Washington Monument American Indian museum Hirshhorn museum Air and Space museum Museums at minimal risk of flooding Museums at risk of flooding Areas at risk of flooding Washington Pennsylvania Ave. African American History museum Natural History museum Constitution Ave. American History museum 3rd St. National Mall Air and Space museum Washington Monument Hirshhorn museum American Indian museum .2 MILES Note: Areas at risk show a 100-year flood zone in 2020. Sources: First Street Foundation; Open Data D.C. By Taylor Johnston Smithsonian officials want to build flood gates and other defenses, and move some collections to a proposed site in suburban Maryland. But Congress has yet to fund many of those efforts, and the changes would take years to implement. Until then, the Smithsonian struggles with this fact: an institution that is beloved by the public, well funded and staffed by top experts is protecting the nations treasures with sandbags and garbage cans. We follow rain like you wouldnt believe, said Nancy Bechtol, head of facilities for the Smithsonian. Were constantly watching those weather forecasts to know whether weve got one coming. On a recent morning, a group of employees gathered in the entrance hall of the American History Museum to point out the places where the water comes in. The hall featured a wooden cotton planter used by a South Carolina tenant farmer. A Super Surfer skateboard ridden by Patti McGee, the first female professional skateboarder. The cream-colored Fender Esquire that Steve Cropper played when he recorded (Sittin On) The Dock of the Bay with Otis Redding. Definitely, where were standing could flood, Ms. Bechtol said. She fears a massive storm that lingers the way Hurricane Harvey in 2017, or New York City this summer. The building manager, Mark Proctor, led the group to Southern Railway 1401, a towering steam locomotive made in 1926. The train sits by a window that looks out onto a garden on the buildings east side. In March, a storm flooded the garden. Water came through the window and pooled around 1401s steel wheels. We had to wet-vac the water out, Mr. Proctor said. Outside, staff pushed flood barriers against the windows to slow the water the next time it floods. Mr. Proctor took a freight elevator to the basement, then entered a room that holds electrical and HVAC equipment that form the buildings life-support system. Without it, the air would turn hot and humid, damaging the collections. Mr. Proctor gestured to a wall. Thats where the water was coming into the building, he said, recalling the March storm. Nearby was one of the buildings two emergency generators, which Mr. Proctor hopes to relocate to the fifth floor. Your generators not going to work if its in the water, he said. Next to the mechanical room, Robert Horton stopped at a locked door. Mr. Horton is . His favorite item at American History is a homemade prosthetic leg made by a coal miner around 1950. After passing his badge over an electronic sensor, Mr. Horton entered a small room with a low ceiling, packed tight with cabinets that held exquisite pieces of porcelain. All the way back, to, you know, the invention of porcelain, he said. When the building was opened in 1964, the basement wasnt designed to store collections, Mr. Horton said. But as the museums holdings grew, it filled up. Mr. Horton walked to the corner of the room where water had come through the ceiling during the March storm. Residue from the water was still visible. Plastic sheeting had been draped atop one cabinet, positioned to direct leaks into a garbage can. Around it were dark squares of fabric, designed to absorb the water that the garbage can missed. Since were afraid that it may happen again, weve left a lot of the protective material in place, Mr. Horton said. Down the hall, another chambers shelves were stacked from floor to ceiling with boxes made of treated paper board that Mr. Horton said were designed to repel water. They were filled with Vaudeville scripts, the papers of Lenora Slaughter, who ran the Miss America pageant from 1941 to 1967, and records from the Depression-era Civilian Conservation Corps, including a box marked Poems of the CCC. Mr. Horton pointed out rows of boxes with documents about Father Charles Coughlin, whose 1930s radio sermons and weekly magazine were described as instruments of anti-Semitism in his . The boxes sat on open shelves, the lowest of which were barely off the floor. In 2006, a storm left three feet of water on Constitution Avenue, which runs along the north side of the museum. Water pushed cars from the street onto the museums lawn and poured into the building. In response, officials to better protect the Mall, including a $400 million pump station. None of those projects were built, in part because responsibility for controlling flooding on the Mall is split among several entities, including the National Park Service, the Army Corps of Engineers, the District of Columbias water utility and the National Capital Planning Commission, said Julia Koster, head of public engagement for the commission. Theres the need to kind of figure out who should lead the charge on this, Ms. Koster said. The Smithsonian, which gets more than half of its funding from Congress and the rest from private sources, has repeatedly requested money from the government since 2015 to start work on a $160 million storage site in Suitland, Md., for items from the American History Museum and the National Gallery of Art. So far, the Smithsonian has put $6 million toward the new storage facility, taken from a larger pot of money earmarked for planning and design. Construction, which was originally supposed to be completed by 2020, has yet to begin. The Smithsonian is seeking another $500,000 to begin work on a separate $39 million plan for flood walls and other changes to fortify the American History Museum. That project is in early planning stages, said Linda St. Thomas, a Smithsonian spokeswoman. Some other Smithsonian museums are farther ahead. The National Air and Space Museum will install flood gates as part of a multiyear renovation expected to total more than $1 billion. The Malls newest addition, the National Museum of African American History and Culture, was built with three massive pumps to keep its lower levels from filling with ground water. Meanwhile, the holdings at American History await a solution. I dont want to rush, said Ms. Bechtol, noting that relocating collections required not only planning and building a new facility but carefully handling each item. We can only really do so much, I guess, and do it carefully and do it well. The tour resumed, passing through a second mechanical room, where groundwater bubbled up through the lowest point in floor, even though it wasnt raining. The history museum sits on , which was filled in during the 1800s. The group emerged into a cafeteria, where floor-to-ceiling windows look out on a quiet garden at the foot of a 35-ton Alexander Calder sculpture. That section of the museum is below street level. The garden slopes up toward 14th Street, forming a giant bowl that fills with water when it rains. Right now, it just comes right in, said Ms. Bechtol, who wants to build a wall around the garden to keep water out. Its like a swimming pool. The tension between protecting the collection and keeping it accessible to the public wont go away in a museum built atop a marsh. For us, the best kind of museum is a closed box with no windows, no doors, Mr. Doyle said, perhaps only half jokingly. It doesnt work too well when youre trying to get visitors. Because of an editing error, an earlier version of this article misidentified the maker of the original Star Spangled Banner, which hangs in the Smithsonians National Museum of American History. It was made by Mary Pickersgill, not Betsy Ross. How we handle corrections focuses on how people, governments and industries try to cope with the effects of global warming. He received a 2018 National Press Foundation award for coverage of the federal government's struggles to deal with flooding.